# S3 E26 T81 BJ's Media Edge - Mark Sluzinski


## [00:00:00] BJ's Wholesale Club & BJ's Media Edge

[00:00:00] 

[00:00:15] **Tom Limongello:** Welcome to the Middlemen Podcast. Todd, we are going to talk to BJ's Wholesale today. We are, talking to a retailer that, is an East Coast favorite

[00:00:27] **Todd:** Uh, I think it's, it's more than an East Coast favorite, and it is, you know, one of the, the big three warehouse chains, right? Alongside Sam's and Costco, who we've spoken to. So now we've sp- spoken to all three, which is awesome, right? We ha- we, we have a good understanding of the space and their evolution and what they're doing.

[00:00:44] And what's interesting is, you know, BJ's hasn't been very public about offering an RMN, and if you hadn't paid attention, you wouldn't even have known, and you would've said, "Oh, just Costco and, and Sam's have it." And it turns out, no, BJ's has had it and had it for a while, and, and it's actually pretty significant.

[00:01:00] And I think we're gonna find as you sort of unturn any retailer who you don't think is doing an RMN, if you unturn their rock, underneath the rock you're probably gonna find a, an RMN there. And so it's not,

[00:01:11] **Tom Limongello:** been working on it or potentially an on-site existing, you know, uh, network that's, that's looking to get bigger, so

[00:01:19] **Todd:** Yeah, though they've been working on it for over five years, which is awesome, and they're trying to be more public, and they're doing some, uh, new things. But I think that, th- that story also in terms of it's fun now as we've been covering the space for a couple of years now, and now talking to more and more of the RMNs themselves, right?

[00:01:35] Talking to Mark at Costco and, and talking to Sam's and talking, you know, uh, now today with BJ's, is hearing some of the differences in their approaches. And they're all... I think that's fascinating, is they're all slightly different and they're at different stages of their journey. Um, and, and they're all doing some different things.

[00:01:52] Like, I think one of the interesting things that pops out here that you love to talk about with BJ's is how they're leveraging coupons within their RMN offering. This is a really cool-- This is actually one of those things, like, I don't even think they realize how cool this is. Um, and I, you know, I think it comes out in the episode, so I th- And you love coupons, by the way, given your background in coupons.com, so it's kind of fun to hear about what they're doing, and I think it's a super cool thing that they've built

[00:02:19] **Tom Limongello:** it's-- I think it's important to figure out how each of these club stores differentiates. And I think with BJ's, if you go into their store, you know, you use their mobile app, you start to see, "Oh, I can save on top of the low prices that are here with coupons." And I think that that drives different purchase decisions.

[00:02:37] **Todd:** That's not the-- You're, you're burying the lede. The lede

[00:02:40] **Tom Limongello:** Tell me

[00:02:41] **Todd:** they have a sponsored coupon slot ad unit. This is

[00:02:47] **Tom Limongello:** you can take that lead.

[00:02:49] **Todd:** No, this is, this is

[00:02:50] **Tom Limongello:** I lived through that,

[00:02:51] **Todd:** But this is-- W- well, but sponsored coupons are not normal, right? This is a great thing. You're doing a search, you can be the sponsored coupon. I l- it's like instead of a sponsored product ad, you have a sponsored coupon.

[00:03:01] It's a super cool idea. And by the way, th- just like we talked about with Sam's and just like we talked about Costco, every time we talk to one of these folks, they say, "Oh, I'm kinda doing this interesting thing," and they don't think so much about it. And I hear about it and I'm like, "There's some cool innovation going on."

[00:03:15] This is a super g- and, and this is what-- And, and they didn't even, I think, realize when they brought it up. I was like, "Oh, I can't believe I didn't think about this before." Like, this

[00:03:23] **Tom Limongello:** Fun to sell!

[00:03:23] **Todd:** Ad slot. Well, it's it's just like, you know, when we talked to Sam's, it was the same thing, right? They have these cool, innovative units that they're doing, and that's the things that I want to, you know, point out.

[00:03:36] Like, when people are do-- like... Go ahead.

[00:03:38] **Tom Limongello:** think, I think to me the, the biggest lede actually, if we wanna talk about why it's significant, is if you think about Sam's, uh, you know, sampling was part of their retail media network, right? With BJ's, uh, coupons are part of merchandising. It's part of the trade and shopper teams. But they are working together with BJ's Retail Media Edge, and so I think that that's the idea is you have all these, uh, tactics at your disposal.

[00:04:03] Are you leveraging them in your retail media network?

[00:04:07] **Todd:** And it's, you know, it's Sam's promoting the sampling, to your point, right, as, as something that, again, the merchandising team is, is probably ultimately selling it, but then the RMN team is promoting it. It's the same thing. The merchandising team here at BJ's selling the coupon program, but ultimately they are RMN promoting it and helping drive units, right?

[00:04:23] And now, you know, BJ's came to us because they're, they're launching their offsite program. They're getting into d- data marketplaces, um, and, and that sort of was their coming out and being public about it. They're gonna be publicly available datasets in programmatic marketplaces, and what's cool about that is they're, they're-- it-- this is a strategy that every large, unique publisher with a subscriber base would be doing.

[00:04:43] And we like to talk about how retailers are being more like publishers, and this is a great example of that. But at the same time, you know, one of the things that I just got-- when I was in the publishing world got me super frustrated was publishers just weren't doing a lot of innovative things. They ran the IAB standard units, they moved into programmatic, they kinda moved into native, like, whatever.

[00:05:02] And what we're finding in the RMN space is because the retailers have unique operating models, right? Costco's is different than Sam's is different than BJ's. They're doing different things.

[00:05:12] And then, you know, they're doing smart things like, yes, you should make your data more available, right? That's the thing all retailers should be looking at is, how do I promote my data in these marketplaces to get in front of brand buyers? Because the way brand buyers work is they go into these dashboards within the programmatic platforms, within these marketplaces, and they start looking for interesting datasets to build campaigns around.

[00:05:32] And it's a way of how do you get attention with these non-endemic buyers is to do that. So c- hats off to BJ's for doing something that, again, publishers have been doing for a long time. RMNs haven't been. They've been really tight with their data, but this is a way to get more attention, and then getting a chance to talk about a super cool ad unit.

[00:05:50] Again, sponsored coupons.

[00:05:52] **Tom Limongello:** I think it's just fun, for us to talk to retail media networks when they're at this inflection point, moving from, a, a finite set of inventory to offsite where they're gonna get a lot bigger. And what does that look like? How, you know, how do they roll that out?

[00:06:05] How do they work with their teams to get there? How do they sell it? And then what does '27 look like for them? So for us, these are-- this is the time when you wanna talk to them. And so that, that for me is, is a lot of fun.

[00:06:17] **Todd:** It's a cool conversation to unlock things. And again, one of the fun things is when the retailer's like, "Oh, I'm just doing kind of this one thing," and I, and we hear about it, we're like, "Whoa, wait, stop. This is cool. Let's talk about that."

[00:06:28] 

[00:06:28] **Tom Limongello:** We're here with Mark Sluzinski of BJ's. BJ's retail media is called BJ's Media Edge. Mark, can you introduce yourself? Tell us, uh, you joined about, what, like a year ago?

[00:06:40] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. Hi, Todd. Hi, Tom. Thanks for having me.

[00:06:42] I'm the director of commercial planning and delivery, uh, at BJ's MediaEdge, um, retail media network. And really what that means is I'm overseeing strategy, sales, and advertising offerings for our retail media program. So really happy to chat with you guys today.

[00:06:55] **Tom Limongello:** Yeah, we, we had a chance to meet up, um, earlier in the spring, and I think it was back in April, and you were like, "We are gonna be opening in Texas." And I think Todd and I know BJ's as an East Coast phenomenon. I'm on, I'm in Philly. He lived, used to live up in Rochester. Um, and so it sounds like you're, you've crossed the Mississippi, and I looked today, there's five stores in the DFW, uh, area that are BJ's with, with the flag on them.

[00:07:20] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, absolutely. So first off, I just wanna kind of talk about BJ's Wholesale Club for the listeners who don't know about us. Um, we are a membership-based warehouse club with more than eight million members and over two hundred and sixty clubs across twenty-two states. We're really focused on how do we deliver exceptional value to our members.

[00:07:36] And as Tom just mentioned, right, one of the most exciting things happening so far this year is we opened stores in Texas. Um, this is as far west as we've been. Um, we opened five in the first half of the year, and we're really excited about what that can mean for obviously the back half of the year, future growth.

[00:07:49] And as we talk about MediaEdge, our retail media network, um, how that kinda helps us to kinda continue to grow and bring value to our suppliers

[00:07:56] **Todd:** I think one of the fascinating things with this, and I was looking forward to it, BJ's is the wholesale club I grew up with in Rochester, New York. It was the first one in, in that market, and so this is the near and dear to my heart of the, of the wholesale clubs. And so it's fun. It's funny 'cause Tom isn't as familiar because they, they weren't in his area, but I grew up with BJ's, and so it's fun.

[00:08:17] And to hear, you know, what you, I think you said is, um, eight million members, it's a pr- it's a really big program in terms of the membership, and it's a really big, um, operation and retailer f- in the wholesale club and as big as, as almost anyone else. And so I think it's a fascinating thing for people who aren't familiar, which is BJ's been around a long time, and it's, it's got people like me who grew up with BJ's.

[00:08:39] And so it's fun to see the expansion both in terms of the footprint, but also now with retail media.


## [00:08:45] Texas Gas Price Splash

[00:08:45] **Tom Limongello:** Um, you know, and You were talking to us a little bit about sort of gas price wars and things as well. So can you tell us what's been going on in Texas?

[00:08:53] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. So I think when we launched in Texas, right, you know, one of the things that we try to do is say, like, "Let's, let's make a splash." Um, so we went out with the $1.99 gas in the Texas markets right around when we are opening those clubs a couple weeks beforehand to kinda really drive awareness and kind of drive new club signups.

[00:09:11] And I think we saw obviously one of our big competitors match that fro- from a gas perspective. So I mean, it's like one of those things where you don't think you're gonna get free publicity, but you do, um, because you're really just driving, "Hey, like, BJ's is here. Um, we're ready to, to be in this market."

[00:09:24] Um, we're super excited, and we got a lot of excitement from our prospective members, um, to say, "Hey, like, wow, I need to check this out." And yeah, gas is one thing, but now you get 'em in a club, and now you can try to get them to obviously become loyal members over time.

[00:09:39] **Todd:** The gas war thing is fascinating for those. It was $1.99 per gallon, um, and it caused huge, massive backups. And when their competitor matched, it was like, it was nuts. Like, it was a whole scene in Texas. I think the entire Southeast might have driven to Texas to buy cheap gas, um, based upon, you know, sort of the coverage of it.

[00:09:56] But I think it's fascinating, right? One of the things, um, that, you know, even when we, when we talked to, um, Harvey from Sam's in a similar way, which is we hadn't necessarily thought through how clubs drive events, like really interesting, big physical events like the gas wars and things like that in Texas, which draws attention.

[00:10:16] And it's this natural landscape for, I think, retail media, which is a natural insertion, right? If there's non-endemic brands, if they had sort of known about that, they might have been all over. Like, you might have been able to give away 5-Hour Energy, you know, sponsored canisters to everyone waiting in the probably five-hour gas line to buy their cheap gas.

[00:10:33] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. Yeah, because I mean, I think this one was, you know, it was like, how do we get our name out there in Texas? A huge, huge market, loyal customer base with a lot of those big grocers, and bam, right? That happened, right? Like, so I think it really makes us think about, to your point, what could that be like down the road, right?


## [00:10:49] BJ’s Offsite Shift

[00:10:49] **Tom Limongello:** You know, when we talked earlier, um, in our preparations, you were talking about a big move to offsite. So do you wanna talk to us about where you are now, maybe what's come over the last five years, and then this big move to offsite?

[00:11:02] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, absolutely. So our program has really been built on owned and operated. So sponsored product ads, display banners, push, brand pages. We've had social thrown in there as well, so we have done some, a little bit of off-site advertising. And then with our previous partner, technology partner, we did do some off-site display.

[00:11:19] But what we really never had was really a true anchor for our off-site offering, and I think that's what's really gonna be changing here as we move into, you know, twenty twenty-seven and beyond, is that we're finalizing a partnership with a leading DSP. We'll be able to leverage our membership data in even a more meaningful way, and I think that's super exciting for what our suppliers are asking for.

[00:11:40] And that's why we're making the move. You know, we've been pushed by our suppliers to say, "Hey, when are you gonna get off-site?" And we're like, "We're working on it, we're working on it," right? And, and we're finally there from a data perspective, a legal perspective. We'll be able to offer managed and self-serve capabilities here as we move into twenty twenty-seven.

[00:11:55] And I think that's really important because that's really how our suppliers are-- want to buy and really work with us as we think about the future


## [00:12:00] Member Data & Audience Strategy

[00:12:00] **Todd:** Well, one of the key components of Offsite is obviously the data, and it... Right? It's one of the key components of even retail media is, is advertisers interested in that. And so you also talked about sort of how you're enabling your data in the marketplace within, you know, the, the programmatic marketplace.

[00:12:16] And, and talk to that in terms of how you're really trying to build the umbrella of, you know, BJ's and BJ's Media Edge, and sort of expand its horizons by making its data more visible across the programmatic landscape as well.

[00:12:29] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we have very rich member data, as we've talked about. We have over eight million members. Um, and so really it's for us to say, how do we get that data in the hands of our suppliers? So what audiences are they looking for? How can we segment that in the way that that's gonna provide value, um, and allow them to transact how they want,

[00:12:45] 


## [00:12:46] Supplier Partnerships and Roadmap

[00:12:46] **Tom Limongello:** over the last five years you've built your onsite capability, um, how do you sort of describe the nature of the relationships you have with your, your vendor community?

[00:12:56] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, I think ins-- our relationships are ever-evolving. I think, you know, we've, we've talked a little bit about, you know, joint business planning and how we're going to market with our suppliers. I think that's one facet of it. I think we've talked about, hey, we can allow us to do both managed and self-serve capabilities from an offering standpoint with our suppliers.

[00:13:14] But I think what's really important is just the level of service that we really wanna provide to them and really allow them to push us to be better from a retail media perspective. As I just mentioned from an offsite standpoint, that came from them saying, "Hey, like, when are you gonna get offsite? When are you gonna get there?"

[00:13:31] Um, we have a lot of those use cases when we think about offsite. We think about in-club, which I know we talked about a little bit today, as well as incrementality as another tool that's gonna be in our toolkit. Um, these are all driven by, yes, what's going on within the industry, but real-time feedback from our suppliers of what they really wanna see from us so they can continue to grow and drive growth at BJ's

[00:13:53] **Todd:** I think one of the interesting things, you know, as we talked and, and Tom and I talked to people in the industry about BJ's, is when people haven't heard as much buzz about a retail media network, they assume it's just a s- a little startup entity operation within a, a, a retailer. And, you know, one of the things that, you know, comes to mind about BJ's is it's more successful than I think people realize.

[00:14:16] It's been quiet, slowly building, you know, delivering, to your point, value for your advertisers. . I don't think people necessarily realize the scale of the relationships you've been able to build. And one of the things that we've heard is that your, your general relationships are probably four to five times larger in terms of the annual relationship with your advertisers than what we're hearing about from others.

[00:14:37] And I think that's an interesting dynamic, which is, - why do you think BJ's has been more successful, again, quietly doing it, delivering obviously value for its advertiser. But why do you think you've been more successful in building some of these bigger relationships than, you know, with, with brands than potentially others?

[00:14:52] And, and obviously the, the key to that is those brands are spending dollars across many RMNs, so they're getting a chance to see what's working and what's not.

[00:15:01] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, I think first I'm gonna start with just how passionate and focused our teams are. I think it's important to recognize how, how this team has built this program across sales, account management, operations, products, analytics, et cetera. And they are truly, like when I say this, like they are invested in making sure every supplier succeeds when working with BJ's.

[00:15:22] I think that that's super important, right? That's number one. I think number two really is that anytime we do a QBR or a mid-year check-in with them, we are super transparent with our suppliers on what our roadmap looks like. What's coming? What does that timing look like? Is it hey, is it a new on-site product?

[00:15:41] Is it, what's going on with off-site, uh, from a DSP perspective? Is it, hey, we're doing some really cool fun testing with incrementality that we've been building over time. We are giving them a look under the hood because I think that's super important so that they know like we're not, we're not just sitting here saying, "Hey, like, you know, we're doing really good growth with you, and you're driving your business."

[00:16:00] We're continuing to invest in our program, and really what we really want from them is feedback on is this gonna make a difference, and is this gonna allow you to say, "Wow, BJ's is a key part of our buy going forward"?


## [00:16:12] Incrementality Testing

[00:16:12] **Tom Limongello:** So what I'm hearing there is that you are, uh, working with some of your vendors as design partners, and you're saying you're testing incrementality. Is that an outsource thing with a vendor, or what, what-- how are you doing that?

[00:16:27] **Mark Sluzinski:** So we're doing that all actually internally today. So we're building incrementality methodology from an on-site perspective as we think of twenty twenty-seven beyond how do we apply that to an off-site. But what we're really doing internally is saying, "How do we, how do we measure incrementality in the right way?"

[00:16:42] Um, test control. How do we be very transparent with our suppliers on our methodology? Um, in Q2, we actually ran some BJ's funded media for some of our key suppliers to really validate our approach and say, "Hey, is this working? Is it providing value?" And what I'm ac-actually excited to share is that we're actually sharing that with our suppliers next week.

[00:17:03] Um, so once, once we actually share this podcast, we would actually have shared this with, with two of our top suppliers, what we're seeing, and really garner their feedback to say, "Hey, does this actually unlock more? What more are you looking for? Do you need more data? Do you need more behind the scenes?"

[00:17:16] How do we get there? Um, that to me is just as exciting as what some of the results are that we're seeing, um, because I think that just shows that, hey, how do we-- how are we really going to bat with our suppliers together and really just building a really strong relationship

[00:17:30] **Tom Limongello:** I don't think I've ever heard a retailer ask, "What more are you looking for?"

[00:17:33] So that's great. 


## [00:17:34] Joint Business Planning

[00:17:34] **Tom Limongello:** When we were talking last time, you were really excited about how the JBP process could continue to be a growth factor for you in the next year do you do upfronts? Like what do you do in terms of your process? How-- Is it the whole year? Is it once or twice a year? Like how does it work?

[00:17:52] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. I mean, I would love for my suppliers to buy on an annual basis. I, I don't, I don't think that, that's definitely not, not the reality of where we're at. and I think most importantly, really, it's about how do we start early, right?

[00:18:03] Like, even just last week, we kind of pulled together a lot of our DMMs and said, "Hey, here's how we want this process to work. Here's how we're thinking about it. Here's the timeline. So let's think about how we can do some first passes from planning.

[00:18:15] Let's collaborate." Like, are certain suppliers gonna see some assortment expansions? Are there gonna be reductions? How are we putting that into planning so that we can really get ahead of it? I think a lot of times we've just been too late. You finish these things up in Q4, early Q1, and if I, if I'm late, then even all these cr- key initiatives might be delayed another year, right?

[00:18:38] From an investment perspective because they weren't thinking about how they could leverage those tactics in the coming year.


## [00:18:45] Club Model and SKU Pressure

[00:18:45] **Tom Limongello:** You know, it's funny, I was, I was having a discussion about this and I was saying for club, um, the merchants are so good, they are so focused on keeping the number of SKUs down. It's very different from grocery where you see, you know, toothpaste for two aisles straight and you're, you know, every SKU possible is on the shelf.

[00:19:05] Um, how does that sort of tension work itself out in retail media?

[00:19:09] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. Yeah, I think from a, um... We haven't gotten to the point where it's like, "Hey, if you do more, do you expand your assortment?" I think it's more of how do we show, "Hey, we have a loyal membership base. We know how often they're coming into our stores. We know how much they're spending," right? Like, we need to think about club as a, as a grocery store, right?

[00:19:29] Like, if you think about the club model, like, I mean, I go into clubs two, three times a month, right? Like, that, that's pretty significant traffic when you think about the pack sizes that our members are buying. And I think it's really about how do we showcase really the value, um, that we can bring, and how can we make sure that their product at the end of the day stays on the shelf, right?

[00:19:51] And it can drive really growth because we know that if, if units don't move, right, like what's next is to come, and we can help support it so it can continue to, to, to kind of evolve and grow

[00:20:02] **Todd:** I think that's an-- to jump in, an interesting point, right? The, the pressure on the vendors to have products that move units in a wholesale club is probably greater than any other retail environment. And they're... Right? It's, it's just a brutal, quote-unquote, marketplace. If they don't move units, they're out.

[00:20:22] And, right, the shelf space is so valuable, the real estate's so valuable. And it's interesting because I hadn't really thought about that in terms of, you know, call it business planning, um, between, you know, the BJs and its vendors, is retail media becomes actually a really almost important factor, not so much just as like, oh, I'm gonna get extra money, but from the perspective of I really care about moving units because I'm gonna lose my, my SKUs, right? Like, they gotta fly off the shelf or they're gone.

[00:20:53] **Mark Sluzinski:** we love, you know, obviously new, new product launches, right? From a, from a merchandising perspective, 'cause you're exactly right. Like, how do we actually, like, showcase that, right? How do we bring that together? Because there's, you know, so much innovation happening across the industry from a product perspective, like things can get lost.

[00:21:11] And how do we, how do we bring that to life? And how do we help them... Uh, as you just said, right, Todd, how do we help them move their units and, um, really keep a, you know, a member, like, super excited about, like, discovery within the store? Like, what's more to come, and why do I need to go in there? Because wow, like, BJ's brought in something new.

[00:21:30] They brought in a new flavor of this. They brought in new candy. They brought in something else. Like, it, it's... It makes the, the shopping experience a lot more fun from a discovery perspective


## [00:21:37] Managed Service vs Self Serve

[00:21:37] **Todd:** You know, as you're selling to those different pockets of customers, where do you see-- What's your perspective on the maturity versus almost immaturity of the market, and what's the difference in the, in sort of your selling go-to-market strategy with those two different types of, you know, very sophisticated, familiar with RMN buyers versus those who aren't used to getting the pitch? 

[00:21:59] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. I mean, I think the sophisticated ones are the things that we hear regularly within the market, right? Like, how is this moving units? And is it moving units? Is it actually working, right? 

[00:22:10] Um, incrementality, right? Like, let's not shy away from that. Like, that, that's what we're gonna hear from the most mature ones. I think from a, you know, some of the ones that aren't as versed, right? It's opening up a conversation, right? I mean, I think we get a lot of inquiries, just referrals through our, you know, BJ's media edge page, right? Of saying, "Hey, like, we'd love to talk about what retail media can be." And surprisingly, like, those can be pretty substantial investments. Um, and I think it's really just how do you take the time to give them the right level of service, show that, " hey, we can, we can manage this for you guys. We can help you drive the investment." I mean, let's get started, right? Let's start very foundational. Sponsor products, yeah, that's display banners. Let's see what we can do, and then let's think through what that can mean longer term overall for your, for your business.

[00:22:54] And a lot of times, those aren't the ones that are saying, "Hey, like I need incrementality on day one," right? They're kinda like, "Let's prove the model. Let's drive more awareness for our products. Let's see what it can do," and really just start to get some really key learnings. So I, I think that, that the, that mid and long tail, Todd, that you're referring to, is definitely ones that, um, I think they're looking for more level of service overall and how can we support them

[00:23:16] **Todd:** I think that's interesting, the managed service angle, right? In terms of, you know, the program's been there five years, you guys are investing in managed services. I think there's been this interesting tension between managed service and self-serve and what does that mean and so forth, and you guys have obviously built a, a full team around this, and it's, it's clearly a part of who and what you are in terms of the market and how you're thinking about it.

[00:23:37] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, abs- absolutely. I mean, I think, you know, I think there's the, the... We want our suppliers to be able to buy how they wanna buy, right? But we know that that's not just gonna be a one size fits all. So we've been very thoughtful and calculated in saying, "Hey, like, do we need a managed service minimum?

[00:23:50] What does that look like? Should we be thinking about that from, hey, what's the-- what are we trying to achieve with that supplier? Is it a hypergrowth brand for the organization? Is it brand new, right? Um, and, and how do we actually lean in? Because, hey, maybe we can help even get them rolling even faster from a top-line sales perspective."

[00:24:13] And really, that just benefits BJ's overall. So I think with like, we, we wanna say like, I, I wanna, I wanna allow suppliers to buy managed if they need to. I want them to do self-serve. If they wanna do managed service on some components and self-serve on others, that's totally fine. Like, I think that's just the reality of where we are in the market, but how do we make it as easy as possible, um, for some of those smaller guys to get into play?

[00:24:34] Because, I mean, there is definitely dollars to be had, um, and we- we're definitely seeing some really good traction. We have a coffee brand that, you know, launched with us, done some really good volume, um, and reinvesting it. And that, that's super cool to see because it's ones that quite frankly sometimes I don't even know about and/or I haven't heard about that brand, and you're like, "Oh my gosh, wow."

[00:24:52] Like, that's amazing. Significant investment for one month. It's pretty cool to see


## [00:24:57] Merchants and Coupon Strategy

[00:24:57] **Tom Limongello:** Yeah, and one thing that was interesting that you said earlier was that this is all about the team. And what's the definition of the team? Is it just the retail media team? Is it the merchandising team? Because, for me, one of the more interesting things about BJ's is that you have really a, a robust set of coupon tactics, um, whereas the other club stores don't really lean into it as much as you guys do.

[00:25:23] And so I wanted to hear, when you talk about the team, is it the merchant team as well? How does that all work for you guys?

[00:25:29] **Mark Sluzinski:** So great question, Tom. I think we-- when we think about team, I think about obviously we have a retail media team. We have a really strong analytics team. We have a really strong data science team. Like, those are all key components, right, as we think about building a, a retail media network and, and success.

[00:25:45] Then it's the partnership with the merchants, which I think, you know, we talked a little bit about joint business planning and evangelization, um, throughout this episode, right? Like we have really strong merchant partners that are starting to really buy in. I would say they, they, they've been bought in, but I think as we are continuing to show really sustained growth for our program and having them hear more in market about, oh, wow, like retail media, retail media, like they're, they're getting validation too that this is super important.

[00:26:14] Um, but then even with some of the things that are coming, right? I've said the incrementality like four or five times probably in the last five minutes, but like that's a key thing that our merchants want to-- want us to deliver on. Because what that does is it changes the game on as you think of trade funds, like where do some of those trade funds go?

[00:26:30] Do they go invest in coupon? Do they go invest in store? Do they go to retail media, right? Like it, it sometimes it might be shifting, but how do you provide the best value for those dollars, um, from a merchandising perspective and from a supplier perspective to, to really move the needle? From a coupon standpoint, do you want me-- I, I'll hit on coupons real quick too, right?

[00:26:47] I think coupons are a really important part of BJ's. You know, one of our key focuses is how we provide undeniable value to our members. And coupons is a really tangible way to do that, right? Like it creates a really strong connection. No joke, right? I, I keep a book next to me, right? It's a seventy- seventy-two-page coupon book of offers that members are able to clip, cut out, bring to store.

[00:27:13] Um, surprise and delight is what I like to think about these coupon books because it's really like, what, what's the next reason for me to shop at BJ's? Um, we call them Smart Savers events, is what we call them internally. Um, but really it's, it's a reason to shop three, four-week timeframe

[00:27:28] **Tom Limongello:** yeah. I mean, I think what's interesting to your point about three to four-week timeframe, Club has been mostly treasure hunt, right? But if there's planning that's happening with paper or in the mobile app or online, I see that as a way to potentially optimize the mix of what people are buying.

[00:27:48] So I think that treasure hunt happens in the store

[00:27:51] based on what you're promoting and the, and the good work that the merchants do. But why am I going to the store or when am I gonna pull the trigger and make the trip happen? I think the coupons sort of grease the wheels to some extent. I mean, this obviously-- I came from coupons.com/quotient, and we always were really rattling everybody saying like, "You need to look at this as a tactic that is part of your retail media."

[00:28:14] And it sounds like it's owned by the merchant in your world. Um, but if you work together, it, you know, without it, it's very hard to sort of get brands that are already well-known to fly off the shelves.

[00:28:28] **Mark Sluzinski:** Absolutely. I think coupons is one of those things, like you said, merchants own it. We can help amplify it. And when we amplify it, what's unique with us, we're a membership-based model, we can tie back all those purchases from a performance perspective, which I think makes it super unique, um, within the industry.

[00:28:42] It gives us a huge advantage, um, overall

[00:28:46] **Tom Limongello:** Well, I mean, you said that you have an analytics team, a strategy team. Yes, incrementality is an important piece of this, but what are the strategy and insights about suggesting to the brands where they should be putting promotions out and where, you know, on which type of consumer? A lot of the times, you know, people st- talk about first-party data and they're like, "Oh, we know these consumers really well."

[00:29:06] If you don't use tactics like coupons, you may not know how loyal they are to certain brands. And so they're, you know, those types of things I think get missed just because it's, "Oh, that was part of shopper marketing. We don't need to think about that."

[00:29:18] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah. So it's really how, how do we bring those together and how, how do we showcase all the value and hit the, hit the member on different touchpoints? And I think that's really where we're, we wanna get to is when you think about offsite, when you think about in club, like different ways that we can, "Hey, you know, Tom, you saw...

[00:29:34] You, you got the print book, right?" Todd, I know we might not be sending one out to the West Coast to you, but you got, you got that print book. But then, "Hey, now I saw it on offsite," but then, "Hey, now I, now I actually saw it in store," and I'm like, "Oh my gosh, like, now it's my time to buy." Um, I love this aspect of the club model, right?

[00:29:50] The coupons, the savers, right, aspect of it because it's, um, just another reason to capitalize on value on things that you may not even know you need, right, at, at the time. But you know if I don't get it then, do I need to wait two, three, four months for it to go on, on sale again? And that keeps that kinda urgency, it keeps that discovery, it keeps that mindset, um, really top of mind.


## [00:30:12] Sponsored Coupons

[00:30:12] **Todd:** With that, and you talk about amplification is really the role that you have in coupons, do you all have special formats and templates for that? Like, are you showing a coupon like creative? What's sort of the dynamic from the amplification standpoint? 'Cause I think that's also interesting in the sense of how it's tied together

[00:30:28] in the...

[00:30:28] Right? 'Cause I'm like, "Oh, they're amplifying it." My, you know, as a, as a hardcore ad guy, um, my immediate mind frame goes to, "Oh, what does it look like?" And are you amplifying the coupon, you know, it, it, this content, the offer in the media itself?

[00:30:43] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, so there's two ways we can do it. One could be on a standard IAB banner, and that could be on our, on our coupons page. The other one that our suppliers really love is if you go to our coupons page and you can go click coupons, our suppliers have the ability to basically boost their coupons up by investing.

[00:31:00] So you, you really say, "Hey, I wanna activate

[00:31:03] **Todd:** It's like a sponsored coupon

[00:31:04] **Mark Sluzinski:** unit." It's, it's, it's basically exactly, Todd. It's a

[00:31:06] **Todd:** That is actually cool, right? That's actually very unique. I haven't heard of anyone offering effectively a sponsored slot in the coupon listing, right? Very analogous to PLAs.

[00:31:16] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yep

[00:31:17] **Todd:** And, but it, a, a sponsored coupon is actually kind of a

[00:31:19] **Tom Limongello:** Getting some PS- PTSD based on these discussions I

[00:31:23] **Todd:** great idea.

[00:31:23] I'm surpri- again, it's a great idea. This is a, it's a brilliant idea. I'm surprised I, we haven't heard about this 10 times already

[00:31:29] **Mark Sluzinski:** Right? So it's like when, when you're in there, and, and what's really cool about that is it's all curated by member. So yay, Todd, we know what your shopping behavior is. Yes, there's all these coupons out there, but hey, when we rank all those, we're gonna say, "Hey, like, which are the ones that are the most relevant?"

[00:31:43] That being, being-- that are being sponsored by suppliers. So my experience is gonna be different than yours, it's gonna be different than Tom's. Um, and that it's, it's super unique, but it's really cool on how you can kinda tie all that together, um, starting from a book,

[00:31:57] **Todd:** Yeah. No, no, it's great. I love the idea of the sponsored coupon slot.

[00:32:00] **Tom Limongello:** Well, when I, when I go to BJ's, I'm playing around with it on the mobile app in the store 'cause I'm not, I'm not as good at planning out the shop. I'm, I'm-- I do it in, in situ. But it Changes the game a little bit, um, in terms of what I'm focusing on. I was saying I had like PTSD. This was the kind of stuff that I did for Albertsons and Dollar General, and it was, it was a real fight over, you know, what- whatever the creative was in like the IAB standards. It was how much goes, how much equity goes to the brand versus how much goes to the retailer.

[00:32:28] Um, and then if there's a promotion involved, you've got, another variable there. So I'd love to see if that has evolved, uh, since I was doing this back in like the early 2020s.

[00:32:37] **Mark Sluzinski:** I think the real cool thing about... Last thing I'll say about the sponsored coupons is very low lift from our suppliers, right? Like from a, from a creative standpoint, it, it the same look and feel. It's just, hey, you're basically boosting and sponsoring that, that unit, um, and getting it in the prime real estate where you know the, the member's engaging

[00:32:53] **Todd:** I, I'm surprised, you know, it-- we haven't heard about this from the, the grocery space more specifically, right? Versus the club. It's a natural for other environments. Um, there's other places where coupons are popular. So gr- you know, kudos for being a kind of a, an innovator in this regard. I think it's a great idea

[00:33:10] **Mark Sluzinski:** They love it. Our suppliers love it

[00:33:12] **Todd:** Oh, I bet. I bet that I, Again, it's one of those things, once you hear a good idea and I think it's one of those, it's like, so our listeners probably go, "Oh my God, I can't believe we didn't think of that." Like, I swear to God, we're gonna hear this echo across the RMN landscape who listen to us and be like, "Oh, I, we should have totally been doing that."

[00:33:26] **Tom Limongello:** Okay. 


## [00:33:27] What's Next for BJ's Media Edge

[00:33:27] **Tom Limongello:** we're getting close towards Q4. Um, what are you gonna be doing to get the word out about BJ's? You know, what events are you gonna be at? What, how, where will we find you in the fall?

[00:33:39] **Mark Sluzinski:** I think, you know, for us, like we, we haven't done a ton of, you know, events. We haven't done a lot of PR stuff. I think this is really our first kind

[00:33:46] of, you know, podcast

[00:33:47] that, that, that, that, that, Yeah, 

[00:33:49] **Todd:** d- the, I feel the debutante ball here for you

[00:33:51] **Tom Limongello:** Yeah, this is great. Yeah, I ran into your team at the, um, the Commerce Media Brand Summit down in Atlanta, and that was the first time I had seen anybody from BJ's out in the wild. So yeah, I'm happy that I, I was able to see you guys at that smaller event.

[00:34:04] Um, but yeah, I mean, I, I think you guys should be talking more

[00:34:07] **Mark Sluzinski:** Yeah, I think we should. I mean, I-I've, I've loved this. I think, you know, we've been definitely saying, like, how do we get our BJ's Media Edge out there from a marketplace perspective? Um, we're doing a lot of really fun things. , I think that, you know, we are definitely in that growth mode.

[00:34:20] Um, but we've been very, uh, kind of focused on kind of like saying like, "Hey, where's the right time to share?" And this time's now. Um, so, so super glad that my team ran into you guys

[00:34:27] What this team has built, you know, I'm lucky to have joined right a year ago. I mean, we have a passionate team that is just like, wants to deliver for, for our suppliers, right? And drive growth, and it's super energizing to come work every day, work with them, see the...

[00:34:43] See, see what they bring to the table and say, "How, how do we, how do we do more? And how do we challenge," right? In, in the right way. And I think that's what, that's what keeps us busy, that's what keeps us energized, um, and allows us to, to really, you know, have built a really strong business, you know, over, over the last five years, and I am super excited about where we're gonna take it.

[00:35:01] Um, and I think their suppliers will be as well.

[00:35:04] **Tom Limongello:** Well, thanks for letting us be the first one to talk about it, and, uh, keep in touch with us. We wanna hear how it goes towards the end of this year and into '27.

[00:35:13] **Mark Sluzinski:** Awesome. Thanks guys. I've really enjoyed this 

[00:35:15] 
